Our two sections — North Coast and Central Coast — announced their brackets Sunday for the football playoffs. As usual, there were some head-scratching decisions.
Most of it occurred in the North Coast Section. This year nine of the 55 teams in the seven divisions are under .500. Some teams are in divisions they’re too strong for, others are in divisions in which they can’t compete.
Seeding the playoffs is difficult, and I don’t question that the folks in charge do the best they can. But some rules have to change, especially in the NCS.
Why are NCS divisions partly enrollment-based and created before the season? In Division IV, you end up with Mt. Diablo playing at Marin Catholic in the first round.
Mt. Diablo was 4-5 this season. It hasn’t been to the section playoffs in football since 2009. During that span it has gone winless four times and had just one win in two other seasons. Marin Catholic is a power. It hasn’t missed the playoffs since 2007. It hasn’t won fewer than 10 games in a season since 2008.
The NCS needs to adopt a system like the one used by the CCS.
Forty schools are placed in five eight-team divisions based on a points system too long to explain here. It’s not perfect. Two 3-7 teams are in the playoffs. Don’t care how tough their schedules were, they lost 70 percent of their games. That kind of performance is an ‘F’ on any mid-term.
The NCS could go with seven eight-team divisions. Only they’re not created before the season. The playoffs become more balanced and competitive. Deserving teams aren’t excluded.
Castro Valley finished 6-1 after a poor 0-3 start, suffering only a one-point loss to MVAL/WACC Mission champion Encinal in those last seven games. Vintage was 6-3, won its last five, shared the Vine Valley title with Casa Grande and beat two playoff-bound league rivals by a combined 74 points. But they lost to Casa Grande 46-44.
If NCS teams had been seeded 1-56 based on a similar system used by CCS, Castro Valley and Vintage would have been in.
The postseason should reward the most deserving teams. The CCS, for the most part, does that.
The NCS should, too.
— Mike Lefkow